Settlers Mill Real Estate
Most Popular
209 Mill Stream WAY
$575,000
Most Expensive
108 Mill View Circle
$759,950
Least Expensive
209 Mill Stream WAY
$575000
Settlers Mill Listings Summary
Settlers Mill - Town vs. County Stats
Avg Price in Settlers Mill: $636,700 / County Avg $637,100
100%
Avg Taxes in Settlers Mill: $4,900 / County Avg $4,000
122%
Avg Sq. Ft. in Settlers Mill: 2,691 / County Avg 2,688
100%
Avg Price per/sqft in Settlers Mill:$237 / County Avg $237
100%
Avg Walkscore in Settlers Mill: 15 / County Avg 7
201%
Avg Year Built in Settlers Mill: 1996 / County Avg 2008
99%
Avg Days on Website in Settlers Mill: 8 / County Avg 61
13%
Settlers Mill Real Estate Market Health
New Listings
Foreclosures
Short Sales
Copyright© 2026 REIN Inc. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. The listings data displayed on this medium comes in part from the Real Estate Information Network Inc.(REIN) and has been authorized by participating listing Broker Members of REIN for display. REIN's listings are based upon Data submitted by its Broker Members, and REIN therefore makes no representation or warranty regarding the accuracy of the Data. All users of REIN's listings database should confirm the accuracy of
All or a portion of the multiple listing information is provided by the Williamsburg Multiple Listing Service, LLC, from a copyrighted compilation of listings. All WMLS information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are ©2026 Central Virginia Regional Multiple Listing Service, LLC. All rights reserved.
All MLS listings are © 2026 Williamsburg Multiple Listing Service, LLC. All rights reserved. No one may copy and/or repost these MLS listings, or any portion thereof, without the written permission of an authorized officer of the Williamsburg Multiple Listing Service, LLC.
All listings with the WMLS logo are provided courtesy of the IDX program.
Last Updated: September 21, 2026 3:39 PM UTC
